Immigrants and the Economy
(From the
National Immigration Forum)
Immigrants wear many hats in American society.
They are family members, students, workers, business owners, investors,
clergymen, and members of the armed services-to name just a few
of their roles. According to the most comprehensive study ever done
on immigrants, the National Academy of Sciences (NAS) found that
in all their combined roles, immigrants make indispensable contributions
to our economy. They compose an increasingly essential proportion
of our workforce. Through their tax payments, they help finance
the costs of schools, health care, roads, welfare payments, Social
Security, and the nation’s defense. Of course, immigrants
are also users and beneficiaries of these government programs.
Immigrants are
a Plus for our Economy - Immigrants and their children
bring long-term economic benefits to the United States as a whole.
Immigrants add about $10 billion each year to the U.S. economy.
This estimate does not include the impact of immigrant-owned businesses
or the impact of highly skilled immigrants on overall productivity.
Immigrants Pay
Their Way - By conservative estimates, immigrant
households paid an estimated $133 billion in direct taxes to federal,
state, and local governments in 1997. The typical immigrant and
his or her descendants pay an estimated $80,000 more in taxes than
they will receive in local, state, and federal benefits over their
lifetimes.
Naturalized Immigrants
Pay More than Their Share - Immigrants who become
U.S. citizens typically pay more in taxes than do native-born Americans.
Adult, foreign-born, naturalized citizens actually have higher adjusted
gross incomes (averaging $40,502) than families with U.S.-born citizens
only ($35,249). Federal taxes paid by families with a naturalized
citizen average $6,580 per year compared with $5,070 for U.S.-born-only
families.
Immigrant-Founded Businesses Are
an Important Revenue Source - Businesses founded
by immigrants are a source of substantial economic and fiscal gain
for U.S. citizens. Ten high-tech firms founded by immigrants, generated
$28 billion in revenues in 1996. These and other businesses started
by immigrants add at least another $29 billion to the total amount
of taxes paid by immigrants.
As They Assimilate, Immigrants Become
Net Economic Contributors - Immigrants’ earnings
rise over time as they climb the economic ladder of success in America.
In their first years in the United States, immigrants typically
are a net cost to the country, but over time— usually after
10 to 15 years in the United States—they turn into net contributors.
An Education and Training Windfall
- Most immigrants arrive in the United States in the prime
of their working years. More than 70 percent of immigrants are over
the age of 18 when they arrive in the United States. That means
there are roughly 17.5 million immigrants in the United States today
whose education and upbringing were paid for by the citizens of
the sending country, not American taxpayers. The windfall to the
United States of obtaining this human capital at no expense to American
taxpayers is roughly $1.43 trillion. This makes immigrants a fiscal
bargain for our country.
Immigrant
Workers are Essential to the U.S. Economy - During
the recent unprecedented expansion in the American economy, immigrant
workers were essential in filling jobs ranging from computer programmers
to hotel and restaurant workers. As America's workforce ages, and
the "baby boomers" retire, immigrants will again play
an essential role in reducing a long-term projected labor shortage.
The U.S. Department of Labor projects that between 1998 and 2008,
the number of jobs will increase by 20 million, but the number of
workers will increase by just 17 million. Federal Reserve Chairman
Alan Greenspan has repeatedly commented that, when labor markets
are tight, immigration is an important source of workers. With the
U.S. labor supply projected to shrink relative to the number of
jobs, Greenspan says that "there is an effective limit to new
hiring, unless immigration is uncapped."
Immigrants Are
Net Contributors to Social Security and Medicare -
The total net benefit (taxes paid over benefits received) to the
Social Security system in today’s dollars from continuing
current levels of immigration is nearly $500 billion for the 1998-2022
period and nearly $2.0 trillion through 2072. Our population is
aging, and each worker will be supporting a growing population of
retirees. Immigrant workers will be an essential component to solving
the long-term problem of financing Social Security.
New Rules to Affect Fiscal Calculations
- Working-age immigrants who have been in the United States
for more than ten years are less likely to receive welfare than
the native-born. The exceptions, because of their special needs,
are refugees and elderly immigrants. Welfare rules enacted by Congress
in 1996 have made newly-arrived immigrants ineligilbe for most welfare
benefits. This change will significantly affect cost/benefit calculations
in the future, making the net fiscal benefit of immigrants even
higher than it is today.
Beyond Fiscal Calculations
- Overall, immigrants are a fiscal bargain for American taxpayers.
Of course, the value of immigrants is not primarily measured by
the dollar calculation of their fiscal impact. Immigrants contribute
to America in many ways other than the size of their tax payments
and the amount they pump into our economy. Their enrichment of our
culture and the overall vitality they bring to American society
are immeasurable in fiscal terms. They are a vital benefit to all
Americans.
S O U R C E S :
National Research Council, National Academy of Sciences, The
New Americans: Economic, Demographic, and Fiscal Effects of Immigration,
National Academy Press, 1997
Stephen Moore, A Fiscal Portrait of the Newest Americans
(Washington, DC: National Immigration Forum and Cato Institute,
1998).
Alan Greenspan, Technology and the Economy, Remarks before the Economic
Club of New York, NY, January 13, 2000.
Ibid., Statement before the Committee on Banking and Financial Services
U.S. House of Representatives February 17, 2000, <http://www.house.gov/banking/21700gre.htm>
____________________________________
© 2003 Hotel
Employees and Restaurant Employees International Union
|